BigGovernment today has a piece up about the “Unhappy Anniversary of the Chicago Tea Party”, calling the Chicago Tea Party movement “a corpse”.
Here’s our take on all this, as people who were there for the first Tea Party, who marched in the demonstration, and who spoke at Tea Party events.
The problem with the Tea Party “movement” in Chicago is that it was, from the beginning, not an organic movement at all. It was 100% orchestrated by political candidates and the Heartland Institute, which is a conservative political think tank here in Chicago.
The first Tea Party demonstration was co-opted by Dan Proft, a political consultant in Cicero, IL who makes a lot of money off that city by billing repeatedly for the same PR services, using a redundancy scheme where he gets paid once for publicizing City Hall or the town park, then gets a second check for “doing PR work” for the street those buildings are on. So, it’s like renting someone a “horse”, but then charging them a second fee for “the legs”, “the head”, “the tail”, etc.
Dan Proft, back in February 2009, thought he was a legitimate candidate for Governor. He, pretty much, was the only one who thought that. He used the Tea Party as an excuse to collect emails and try to build a groundswell of support for his campaign. Proft is a lot of things, bad mainly, but he’s sure a fantastic operator when opportunity emerges. He saw the potential in the Tea Party spirit overtaking millions coast to coast who are fed up with the reckless spending of the government. He saw people on television tapping into that Tea Party anger. So, Proft wanted to channel that energy into political benefit for himself.
One of Proft’s employees, Julie Johnson, became communications director for the nascent “Tea Party Organization” started up by a guy named Eric Odem. Johnson and Odem pushed the Tea Party events in Chicago, on February 27th and on April 15th, 2009.
All the tea hit the fan in the leadup to the April 15th Tea Party when Johnson decided to blacklist a Tea Party event the Chicago Young Republicans were having at Navy Pier later in the day. Here’s what the issue was: Dan Proft staged the April 15th Tea Party in the Loop in Chicago because he wanted to use it to launch his gubernatorial bid. The Heartland Institute funded the stage and sound equipment for that event, and thousands of people were expected to turn up. It would have been a great venue for Proft to benefit from. But, Johnson made the decision to go to war with the Chicago Young Republicans over their evening event…because, as communications director, she did not want the evening news to carry the CYRs’ event at Navy Pier (which had an actual tall ship and the dumping of wooden crates (on ropes to be pulled back on board) in Lake Michigan) instead of footage of Proft speaking at the afternoon Tea Party.
The end result was that Johnson and Proft blinked, and Proft did not speak at the Tea Party in the Loop on April 15th. But, a lot of bad blood remains from what happened. Heartland, which is not supposed to back any candidate, got burned by the Proft connection, and has distanced itself from anything Tea Party since.
Johnson (who is actually a great person, by the way, and is someone we think will be a big player in local politics in the future), left the Tea Party structure shortly after Proft’s involvement in the April 15th Tea Party was exposed. She worked for Proft’s failed gubernatorial bid and apparently continues to work for his political consulting firm now.
We have no idea what happened to Odem, but believe he’s still involved with Tea Parties somewhere…because he sees this as his chance to become very, very rich by tapping into this spirit and turning it into a business opportunity for himself.
When we say people should be wary of the Tea Party “movement”, this is the sort of thing we are talking about.
The spirit is real.
People are angry.
Americans don’t trust the government or the way it’s spending tax dollars.
But, Tea Party supporters should not trust the men and women who purport themselves to be “Tea Party Leaders”.
The danger, in our opinion, is that opportunists like Proft and Odem will usurp the legitimate spirit of the Tea Parties and create their own money-making ventures off them, or in the case of would-be politicians like Proft, co-opt the “movement” for their own campaign purposes.
The reason Chicago’s Tea Parties collapsed is because, sadly, they weren’t ever real to begin with. That is clearly not the case nationwide, but it’s true for Chicago. Proft’s involvement sank any chance of a real, actual, grassroots Tea Party group from forming in Chicago. In truth, the CYRs didn’t stage their Tea Party event for the sake of Tea Parties either. They used it as a membership recruiting drive for their organization (which we supported at the time) and a chance for their grandstanding president to be on TV a whole bunch, looking all manly on a boat. Way to go, stud!
The BigGovernment story didn’t reflect on any of this, but maybe it’s not widely known.
The way things work in Chicago is the way they are working in Washington, now that Chicago’s taken over DC. It’s all about the ego, people. If there’s energy and excitement and opportunity out there, a Chicagoan will try to capture all of that for personal use and enrichment. Don’t come between a Chicagoan and a TV camera when Chicagoans want to promote themselves.
And, if that promotion fails, and if whatever endeavor they’re involved in tanks, they walk away from whatever they were doing. As if it never happened.
Proft and others tried to use the Tea Party to further their own aims, but failed.
And, now that they’ve moved on to new schemes and dreams, they’ve left the Tea Party behind them.
It’s a cautionary tale we try to communicate to everyone who supports the Tea Party spirit, so that what happened in Chicago doesn’t happen elsewhere too.
March 1, 2010 at 5:15 pm
I was at the Tax Day Loop protest.. I was shocked at the turn out.
I thought the stage production was horrible. I couldn’t hear anything.
And that was that.
As a conservative, I have no idea how to protest. I feel stupid yelling in a crowd.
March 1, 2010 at 5:19 pm
It’s too bad that someone else didn’t pick up the tea party spirit and organize a protest in Chicago.
Hopefully someone in that city will get something going for April 15th?
March 1, 2010 at 5:30 pm
I just blogged about this very topic at:
http://saucyusa.blogspot.com/2010/03/tax-day-chicago-tea-party-15-apr-2010.html
comment from that Breitbart article:
“News of the death of the tea party in Chicago has been greatly exaggerated. We’re celebrating the one year anniversary of the first Chicago Tax Day Tea Party with a rally at noon on April 15, 2010 in Federal Plaza. Over the past month we’ve been working with like minded groups across the city and state to not only help organize the rally, but to build an organization that is sustainable after April 15 to help educate voters, walk precincts, make phone calls and get out the vote for candidates that pledge to support and defend the constitution.
We’re going to have nationally known speakers, local liberty activists and regular Americans who’ve made a difference over the past year take the stage – including people you already know.
More information is available at http://www.teapartychicago.org. People are also welcome to contact me directly at steve@teapartychicago.org
Steve Stevlic
Coordinator
Chicago Tax Day Tea Party
Tea Party Patriots Chicago”
March 1, 2010 at 5:59 pm
YAY! Glad to hear it!
March 1, 2010 at 5:31 pm
If the tea parties are to revive in Chicago it needs to be grassroots. It needs some kind of leaders… but not paid ones.
People in Chicago still need a voice… they need to at least try again for April 15 this year.
March 1, 2010 at 5:35 pm
Death of the Chicago Tea Party seems to be an intentional false meme. From the comments:
News of the death of the tea party in Chicago has been greatly exaggerated. We’re celebrating the one year anniversary of the first Chicago Tax Day Tea Party with a rally at noon on April 15 in Federal Plaza. Over the past month we’ve been working with like minded groups across the city and state to not only help organize the rally, but to build an organization that is sustainable after April 15 to help educate voters, walk precincts, make phone calls and get out the vote for candidates that pledge to support and defend the constitution.
We’re going to have nationally known speakers, local liberty activists and regular Americans who’ve made a difference over the past year take the stage – including people you already know.
More information is available at http://www.teapartychicago.org or http://www.officialchicagoteaparty.com or on our Facebook page.
People are also welcome to contact me directly at steve@teapartychicago.org
Steve Stevlic
Coordinator
Chicago Tax Day Tea Party
Tea Party Patriots Chicago
March 1, 2010 at 5:52 pm
My group, the Southern California Tax Revolt Coalition, has had its eye on Eric Odem for quite some time. Personally, I think he is one of the people a bit too keen on being the “face of the Tea Party”. Odem went on Fox News to deride the organizers of the TP Convention in Tennessee — accusing them I “profiteering”. That lead me to prepare this post, which was widely distributed through the TP networks:
“I do not begrudge a Tea Party group their profits — as that means they are well run, have innovative ideas, and are highly engaged. Tammy Bruce pointed this out during a recent show: Profits mean money; money means power. Our citizen groups MUST have money as well as man-power.
The only thing asked by citizens is full disclosure! Where is the money going? What is the money supporting? ”
http://templeofmut.wordpress.com/2010/02/01/tea-parties-tempests-and-democratic-tea-baggers/
By the way, a real Tea Party group is most effective as a leaderless organization — as explained here: http://templeofmut.wordpress.com/2010/02/17/a-leader-is-a-dealer-in-hope-therefore-there-is-no-tea-party-leader/
I am sharing your observations with as many of my Tea Party connections as I can reach. Thanks for being the eyes and ears in one of the most challenging areas I can think of!
March 1, 2010 at 5:52 pm
See Capra, Frank — “Meet John Doe”.
March 1, 2010 at 5:56 pm
What about the suburbs of Chicago and other smaller communities? I have friends in the burbs and the actively join rallies, meet-ups but do not belong to a party — they are just mad as H— at the Marxist take over attempt.
Also, a lot of pent up frustration by downstaters who quit voting as the say only Chicago rules state elections and why bother? Said they felt renewed hope that others were standing up — and against the Chicago rule of the state.
March 2, 2010 at 4:06 pm
Cary,
If you can’t find one: start up your OWN local TEA party in your area?
Go for it!
May 9, 2010 at 11:29 am
Cary…where are you at please? Maybe I can help you hook up with one, we are starting one in Plainfield….and we need to act fast and need all the help we can get!
March 1, 2010 at 5:56 pm
Hillbuzz:
In the comments to the BigGovernment post, a man named Steve Stevlic, representing himself as “Coordinator, Chicago Tax Day Tea Party, Tea Party Patriots Chicago,” states that the Chicago tea party is not dead and that tea party events are being held on April 15. Do you know Mr. Stevlic?
March 1, 2010 at 5:57 pm
We don’t think we’ve ever heard of him.
March 1, 2010 at 6:15 pm
If the Chicago Tea Party was not organic (arugula?) then Chicagoans were smart to dump it and let it die.
Right from the beginning, Boston Tea Party style Americans have known that both the radical right-wing fringe groups and the radical left-wing fringe groups would try to co-opt the movement like crazy to their crazy ends.
March 1, 2010 at 6:18 pm
I believe he spells his name “Odom” not “Odem”….at least in all the Google references.
March 1, 2010 at 6:47 pm
I wouldn’t count the Chicago Tea Partiers out too soon. They are the ones who went head-to-head with that CNN reporter lady. Chicagoans are not to be trifled with.
March 1, 2010 at 7:15 pm
Ann over at BackyardConservative has lots of info for local Chicago / Illinois peeps.
http://backyardconservative.blogspot.com/
She posted about “the sammies” where Andrew Breitbart will speak… sounds interesting.
March 1, 2010 at 7:15 pm
Off theme — here are Hot Air’s two lates health-care reports:
http://hotair.com/archives/2010/03/01/uh-oh-biden-might-have-power-to-kill-gops-tactics-against-reconciliation/
http://hotair.com/archives/2010/03/01/plan-c-obama-set-to-introduce-much-smaller-health-care-bill-on-wednesday/
This is one of those times when I detect a strong schizophrenic tendency in this Administration.
March 1, 2010 at 7:22 pm
I don’t see the Tea Party as an organization with leaders.
I see the Tea Party movement as an attitude among middle class voters who are tired of a government that keeps screwing them over and ignoring them. Or even worst, looks down on them as stooges to be manipulated.
So if I’m right, it doesn’t matter what any organization does or doesn’t do. What matters is the attitude and the will to do something about it.
But maybe I’m all wrong about this and someone who is closer to the Tea Parties can set me straight. But that’s the way I see it.
March 1, 2010 at 7:32 pm
Genetic Tea Partiers smell an organizer a mile off and if a small group of them notice the organizer, they freeze them out quickly. I hope the Chicago group comes back…more wary. At our first Tea Party in September in our small farm town, guess who showed up: the local Republican Chair–angling for a position of visability. Everyone was courteous to him, just as they were to every other citizen there. He had an opportunity on the mic, just like every other citizen there. It didn’t more than 8-10 minutes before he realized that he just wasn’t consider special by anyone in attendance. So he just enjoyed the evening, like everyone else. The Tea Parties in this area are thriving…and will STOMP anyone who acts like they are think they are important or are supposed to “take over”.
Go, Chicago!
March 1, 2010 at 8:45 pm
I like that.
yep, we are bound by principles. I’ve noticed they endorse people based on the willingness of those running who will adhere to those conservative principles.
I laugh when I hear that Tea Partiers are all repubs… LOL! if they only knew how many independents and yes democrats are part of the movement… maybe then they will stop insulting average patriotic americans who have just had enough!
March 1, 2010 at 7:41 pm
Hey HB,
wanted to bring your attention to this.
Lady Lynn’s latest piece: “I told you so America”
http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2010-02-28/i-told-you-so-america/full/
love love love Lady Lynn!! she was so supportive of Hillary and then campaigned for Sarah.
March 1, 2010 at 10:57 pm
I caught that piece; it is a gem.
March 1, 2010 at 7:46 pm
I think the Tea Party does great without one leader. Each state has essentially its own Tea Party movement, some are more socially conservative, some more liberal/moderate.
The Tea Party in Arkansas will be more socially conservative than the Tea Party in Mass.
But all tea partiers have a few things they staunchly agree on, things like fiscal disciple, pro-growth policies, pro-America policies, strong national defense, strong indiv rights
and that is the beauty of it, its decentralized with common platforms, but they do vary from state to state on other issues, but their platform is based on solid smaller govt, pro-America policies.
And as for what they should do, frankly Tea Party people need to take over both parties, the repubs are a more natural fit, but there are many centerist/conservative dems like me who have been kicked out of the undemocratic party.
keep the tea party movement decentralized and run conservative candidates in both parties.
March 1, 2010 at 8:00 pm
Well every State that has tea parties runs into a few problems.
Like this one in Houston, where some racist creep keeps showing up and the media jumps all over him as the poster boy for Tea Parties.
http://gatewaypundit.firstthings.com/2010/03/revealed-medias-racist-fake-tea-party-leader-is-a-fake-hero-too/
Each group has some loose leadership, as they have to get permits to protest and security and such. But as a whole,I think they’re all pretty independent.
And I LIKE that!
March 1, 2010 at 8:02 pm
Tangential to the Tea Party movement, Doctor Zero has a zinger of a post over at Hot Air:
http://hotair.com/greenroom/archives/2010/03/01/an-alternate-ending-for-the-health-care-saga/
March 1, 2010 at 8:30 pm
I just love the Doc!
March 1, 2010 at 9:16 pm
I don’t believe the Tea party movement in Chicago is dead, Hillbuzz. There are turf wars and personalities happening of course, that’s pretty normal when you have a huge movement that rises to power quickly.
Here’s an article I was reading
“For the Tea Party Movement, Sturdy Roots in the Chicago Area”
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/19/us/19cncodom.html
I think the focus has shifted, too. At first it was about gathering in large groups to send a message to DC. Well, the message was sent and they chose not to listen, so now it’s about kicking them out of office.
March 1, 2010 at 10:00 pm
Very interesting background. I hope you post a link to this piece over at Brietbart’s site. This is extremely informative.
March 1, 2010 at 10:39 pm
Eric Odom has relocated to Vegas to fight to defeat Reid. I believe he is truly in this fight to make a difference. Anyway, here is a link to his Facebook page: http://www.facebook.com/pages/Eric-Odom/195590938431
March 1, 2010 at 10:42 pm
So, what about this faux “Coffee Party”?
If the Tea Party has no power and is dead, then why all the concern and need to create the “Coffee Party”?
I went over to YouTube and watched the “Coffee Party” videos. The one that irritated me the most was the one by the hairdresser who identified himself as “Arab-American” and then began an anti-white racist screed, and stated the Tea Party doesn’t represent “real” America.
Unbelievable.
And this is from a group that states they want
“civil, respectful and cooperative discourse”.
Yeah, so, of course, the way to achieve that is to have your opening salvo slamming Tea Party activists as not “real” Americans and go on an anti-white bashing binge.
FAIL.
Axelrod must be really, really desperate if this is their big “plan” to disarm the Tea Party.
March 1, 2010 at 11:43 pm
I been arguing with those Coffee people idiots all day … here
http://fightinwordsusa.wordpress.com/2010/03/01/bringing-tea-to-the-coffee-party/
I called them out from the beginning to the end about the racism charge.
I find it so funny how the left is so desperately derivative when it tries to attack the Non Left.
It’s so unoriginal.
Coffee Party? That’s pretty desperate.
“Party of No” , the Democrats were being called that in the early 2000s
“Obstructionists”, the Dems were being called that in the early 2000s
I’m a hurry right now to get out of here and get something to eat but there’s a bunch of other things they have appropiated , thinking themselves clever but i cant get them out right now.
March 2, 2010 at 12:06 am
Vince, I went over and put my 2 cents in.
Unfortunately, I have had first hand experience watching Annabel Park and Eric Byler up close during the making of their fauxmentary, “9500 Liberty”. They are disingenuous Obamatron hacks from waaay back.
Coffee Party = Organizing for America v2.0
And they have the same little Axelrod trolls hunched over their keyboards in their mommies basement immediately zapping any YouTube votes for comments that are not pro-Progressive party line or are anti-Coffee Party. Immediately. Zap! It’s almost like it’s orchestrated with a puppet master behind the scenes.
They are so obvious, it’s soooo sad.
March 2, 2010 at 1:51 am
A bit late perhaps, but the Tea Party Palatine group is having a meeting in the Schaumburg Public Library,130 S. Roselle Road this coming Wednesday, March 3rd.
( http://clmijare.webs.com/apps/calendar/showEvent?calID=2951776&eventID=67329541 ).
Another group, the West Suburban Patriots (an Independent Tea Party Group) is having a rally/protest against the government take over of health care in Batavia il on Saturday March 6, from 12:30pm to 2:30pm. ( http://westsuburbanpatriots.ning.com/events/protest-govt-takeover-of )
I’m in chicago but didn’t see any meetings/rallies planned on the chicago tea party website other than the rally on the 15th.
Perhaps a few chicagoans attending the tax day rally will coalesce around an American agenda, I certainly hope so.
In the meantime, attending one or both of these events will certainly help the cause.